Obama a winner by contrast

The Canbarra Times (Australia)

June 6, 2008

Barack Obama is, finally, the presumptive presidential nominee of the Democratic Party. The contest will pit a genuine American hero against the man of destiny. While honouring Republican candidate John McCain as a true patriot, Obama has begun to sketch out his and his wife's compelling life narratives including his white grandfather as a member of the Greatest Generation as a metaphor for the American dream. Republicans hope that in an unloseable election the Democrats have chosen an unelectable candidate. They should be so lucky.

Obama is battered and bloodied, but also the battle-hardened mythic slayer of the famed and feared two-headed Clinton dragon. As the first black president of the prestigious Harvard Law Review, the remunerative world of successful law graduates beckoned. Obama could have been a Supreme Court clerk or gone straight into a top-end law firm. He chose instead to become a community organiser in Chicago, working across racial and other divides, but also nursing a political ambition that aimed not for bit parts but for the stars. His message of unity resonates because he personifies America's contradictions, but also its aspirations and ambitions as the city on the hill. He is the embodiment of the Republicans' great propaganda: that in America anyone with the talent, aptitude and the work ethic can realise the American dream. For them to attack Obama would be to admit the core Republican belief has been a lie.

Both McCain and Obama will claim the high road without leaving the low road. While the candidates directly will try to debate the issues, their surrogates may well dig deep into closets for skeletons. Clinton did Obama a favour by giving his weaknesses and potential vulnerabilities a full airing during the primaries. The country has moved on since Bill Clinton first ran 16 years ago. Race-based identity politics shows a generational divide. McCain is vulnerable to the counter-charge of not being aware how much the nation and the world have changed since he first entered politics.

The smear-and-fear tactics will likely revolve around depicting Obama as a cultural and intellectual elitist aloof from six-pack Joe and Jane, with Muslim family connections, an Arab middle name, and America-hating associates that together make him inexperienced on foreign policy and unsafe on national security. Obama parried this during the primary by expressing revulsion at the peddlers of hate and the merchants of slime, appealing instead to the better instincts of Americans. His message could resonate even more powerfully during the general election campaign as a backlash against the Bush-Cheney years of terrify-and-rule. Unlike Obama, McCain's skeletons, including support and endorsements from fiery white priests and pastors, have not been subjected to the same fierce public and media scrutiny. Already several people have left McCain's camp owing to previous lobbying activities or connections. The Democrats have learnt from the John Kerry experience that not responding swiftly to attacks can cause irreversible political damage.

McCain is weighed down by the millstones of an unpopular president and war and a tanking economy. The answer to the litmus test for incumbent administrations made famous by Ronald Reagan are you better off today? is a resounding ''Hell, no''. Bush's disapproval rating (almost 70 per cent) is the highest since Gallup began polling 70 years ago, higher even than Lyndon B. Johnson, Richard M. Nixon and Jimmy Carter during Vietnam, Watergate and the Iran hostage crisis respectively.

Not just the disaster, but its magnitude, is impossible to conceal. Big budget surpluses have turned into big debt; a nation that was at peace is fighting two nightmarish wars and could be plunged into a third; denial of climate change has put the planet in peril; stable energy prices have given way to skyrocketing prices at the petrol pump; real household incomes have shrunk amid an economic expansion; and an America at the pinnacle of global power and respect is held in nearly universal contempt and disrespect. Little wonder that pessimism prevails and people yearn for change.

Team Obama has proven to be an impressive mix of strategists and managers, idealists and street-smarts. Equally astonishing has been their model of internet-based fundraising, grassroots organisation, long-range planning and political mobilisation that skilfully exploits Obama's rock star appeal. Don't expect him to buy into McCain's challenge of 10 town hall style debates that would give McCain free access to Obama's rock star size crowds. Obama has to avoid alienating his existing broad base, McCain has to work aggressively to expand a narrow support base. McCain is on the losing side on three big issues: the economy, health care and Iraq. His maverick reputation will not be enough to insulate him against being the candidate of Washington. One of the smartest moves the Obama team made early on was to locate campaign headquarters outside Washington, in Chicago. But McCain could win the argument on free trade and paint Obama as an anti-NAFTA panderer. If critics are to be believed, the free trade pact has miraculously exported jobs from every single member to the other two partner countries.

The contrasts, not just in the colour of their skin, but also in age, freshness, vitality and energy not to mention inspiring eloquence and uplifting vision will be cruelly clear every time Obama and McCain share a stage. Will concerns about age and race offset each other? Against persistent rumours of McCain's legendary short temper, Obama is cool personified, a model of grace under pressure. Tellingly, through all the ups and downs, the triumphs and tribulations of a tough and gruelling Democratic contest, Obama has managed to retain not just his good humour, poise and equanimity, but also the respect, admiration and affection of his staff. If the campaign is a pointer to how a president will run his administration, the stars seem aligned.

The opinions expressed in this article/multimedia are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of CIGI or its Board of Directors.

About the Author