The "third way" posting on Afghanistan (October 17) describes the polarized debate on the question of Canadian Armed Forces in Afghanistan:

"The Prime Minister leads the charge for staying the course. Canada is at war, he says, and we don't cut and run - we will stay in this war until the job is done. NDP Leader Jack Layton leads the call for withdrawal. It is the wrong mission for Canada; it is a war with unclear objectives and it can't be won."

The posting goes on to look at some recent proposals and arguments that point to a third option or approach:

"So here are the main elements of an emerging third option: pull out of the south; redeploy to the north in support of training and provincial reconstruction teams; substantially increase non-military aid; review the strategy, objectives, and tactics used by the NATO-led ISAF; and re-open the political process in pursuit of a more inclusive and representative political order for the entire country."

Since then, an October 27 letter sent out by Mr. Layton elaborates a position for the NDP that looks a lot like the "third way":

  • "Give notice that Canada will withdraw from the search-and-kill combat mission in Kandahar." 
  • "Work with NATO partners, the Afghan government, and other affected parties to find a political solution through capacity building and a comprehensive peace process.
  • "Focus Canada's role in Afghanistan on humanitarian aid, reconstruction and development, with appropriate security measures."

A focus on humanitarian aid, reconstruction, and development, assisted by appropriate security is elaborated in a recent press kit prepared by Canadian Women for Women in Afghanistan (available along with other excellent resources at ), a Calgary-based NGO that has been working with Afghan women since 1996:

"Afghanistan needs an international security force, adhering to internationally recognized human rights standards, for a period of at least ten years. This force should have the following main objectives:

  • To provide security and stability for all Afghans;
  • To facilitate safe provision of basic services such as education, clean water, and healthcare;
  • To create an environment where Afghans can take on reconstruction and development activities on their own terms; and,
  • To ensure the security needs of women and girls are met, which include protection from sexual violence, trafficking, rape, and other security threats commonly face by Afghan women."
The opinions expressed in this article/multimedia are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of CIGI or its Board of Directors.