Technological Threats to Our Freedom of Thought

Speaker: Susie Alegre

September 14, 2022

Technological Threats to Our Freedom of Thought

The desire to get inside the human mind — to understand, to judge and, ultimately, to control other people’s inner lives — is not new. Science, religion and those in power down the centuries have made inferences about the thoughts and beliefs of individuals and groups and sought to manipulate or punish. What has changed in recent years is the pace and ubiquitous nature of technological and scientific developments that are specifically designed to get inside our heads.

Technology that is designed to read human beings’ inner lives and to change them raises serious concerns about the effective protection of the forum internum — and it is everywhere. Emotion recognition technology can be used to predict a person’s state of mind. That information can be used to change how they think, feel and, ultimately, behave. It can also be used to make predictions on criminal activity or as evidence in legal proceedings. Researchers claim to be able to read our sexual orientation or political opinion from biometric data, which, in some parts of the world, can have dire consequences for people.

CIGI Senior Fellow and international human rights lawyer Susie Alegre explains the importance of protecting our inner thoughts from technology’s encroachment. Freedom of thought is protected absolutely in international human rights law at the United Nations level. It includes the right to keep our thoughts private, the right not to have our thoughts manipulated and the right not to be penalized for our thoughts alone.

In this video, Alegre outlines the importance of protecting humanity’s inner freedom first and foremost when discussing all aspects of technology governance issues.

Did you know that international law protects freedom of thought?

This means that you have the right not to be manipulated, to keep your thoughts private and not to be penalized for your thoughts alone.

That seems simple enough — how could anyone know what you’re thinking and use it against you?

Sadly, our inner freedom is threatened by technological and scientific developments specifically designed to get inside our heads.

Here are just a few examples:

Emotion recognition technology can be used to predict our state of mind — are we happy, sad or angry? That information can be used to change how we think, feel and, ultimately, behave.

But it can also be used to predict whether we are thinking about committing a crime. Or as evidence used to prove states of mind in legal proceedings.

Researchers claim to be able to read our sexual orientation or political opinion from biometric data, which, in some parts of the world, can have dire consequences for people.

The line between our inner self and the outer world is increasingly being blurred by technology. It’s important that we stop this invasion on our inner lives and set clear barriers where technology cannot enter.

As regulators look to address all aspects of tech regulation, from content moderation, AI bias and oversight, data collection and so on, we need to focus on the human, not the machine.

So, where do we begin?

As I said at the beginning of this video, our freedom of thought — in the forum internum, as it’s called — is already protected absolutely in international human rights law at the United Nations level.

New rights aren’t needed to meet the modern challenges. Sadly, however, these rights have been largely neglected, especially in relation to technology.

At the United Nations, a special envoy could be appointed to change the strategic focus from the technology to the protection of our inner freedoms — providing a holistic response to the challenges we face.

Or a new convention clarifying the practical protections needed to guarantee freedom of thought would be a useful tool for nations at a domestic legal level.

Technology will shape our human future. We are at a crossroads, where we need to decide how to ensure that humanity is at the heart of that future.

For media inquiries, usage rights or other questions please contact CIGI.

The opinions expressed in this article/multimedia are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of CIGI or its Board of Directors.